An attempt to understand what happened last night: What
follows are my thoughts on what occurred in last night’s presidential election.
Let me preface these remarks by stating that I did not vote for president for
the first time in my life (I did go and vote, I just left the presidential line
blank) so I feel that gives me some unique leeway to discuss the results by
having no dog in this fight. While I have never voted a straight ticket, I tend
to vote Republican more often than Democrat. My goal is to always vote for the
person that most reflects my values and policy views, as well as to vote for a
person of solid moral character. I have voted against Republican candidates
that held many similar political beliefs to my own because I considered them to
have dubious moral character. While I did not vote for Trump I believe that I
understand much of what drove many of them to cast their ballot for him. I want
to provide context and understanding to Trump’s victory as a mostly
disinterested third party. So that’s where I’m coming from with this post. As
always, it is my desire to encourage discussion, understanding and interaction
between my friends of all political stripes, beliefs, etc.
Prior to Election Day it was my true belief that no matter
which of the two candidates was elected, the result was going to be bad for the
country. Somehow our primary process resulted in the two worst possible choices
for our country. For the first time in our nation’s history we were given the
choice between two candidates with disapproval ratings of greater than 50%. The
hacked DNC emails show a high level of coordination and the Clinton campaign to
help Democrat primary voters make the “right” choice. If a candidate needs to collude
with party officials to win a primary, perhaps that candidate is the wrong
choice to lead the party. She was a known factor that the general populace has
been rejecting since the 90s. The Republican Party did no better by allowing 17
(!) candidates to duke it out for the nomination ensuring that none of them
were able to secure a majority of voters. Yes Trump won a strong plurality, but
I’m not sure that happens in a limited field. My thought regarding these two
candidates was that in a worst-case scenario, one would lead to a world war and
one would lead to a civil war. Do you want to shove your foot in a blender or
your hand?
Now that one of the two worst candidates in modern history has
been elected let’s try to understand what happened and figure out how to keep
it from happening again. First, to my left-leaning friends, stop your tantrums
and get your stuff together. We are not instituting a gestapo, we are not
returning to the time of Jim Crow and no one is getting ready to start Elian
Gonzales style raids in the middle of the night. If any of that were to take
place I will be one of your most ardent defenders and will happily rally
defenders to your cause. The discussion that plays out daily between the left
and right is an important one so that we as a people can make an informed
decision about how we want to grow and shape our culture. This has happened.
The democratic process has spoken. Stop with the wailing and gnashing of teeth
and let’s all figure out how to fix this. This is how many conservatives felt when Obama was elected. We survived that. We will survive this.
Relatedly, Trump winning does not mean that a significant
chunk of the population is stupid, racist, sexist and bigoted. In any large
group of people there are going to be those to whom those labels apply (this is
true of both the left and right). Did Trump use a lot of rhetoric that was
uninformed, racist, sexist and bigoted? Yes, absolutely and it was deplorable.
In any other election, against any other candidate he would not have had a
chance. Hillary was the exact wrong candidate with the exact wrong message at
the exact wrong time. Did states that voted twice for Obama suddenly become
racist in the last 8 years? Are blacks and Latinos that voted for Trump in
higher numbers than Romney racist? Was it due to sexism that fewer women voted
for Clinton in 2016 than for Obama in 2012? Perhaps part of the problem is that
the party of identity politics has villainized the largest voting bloc (working
class whites) for so long that they finally said enough and voted as a bloc for
the first time. Perhaps the fact that the Affordable Care Act is in a death
spiral and premiums are sky-rocketing didn’t help (as an insurance agent I
receive calls on a daily basis looking for other options when none exist).
Perhaps it was the failure of both political and urban elites to realize that
they can’t merely wish the economy to be fine while much of the non-urban
country is experiencing either high levels of unemployment or historically low
levels of the workforce participation rate.
To call these voters stupid, racist, sexist and bigoted is a
pithy means of comforting yourself and reinforcing your view of your own moral
superiority. It misses many of the lessons of this catastrophic election, and
without serious soul searching will doom us to repeat our mistakes. This was
not an election dominated by racism and sexism, but rather one that runs along
class lines (working class vs. elites). Those that fall into the elite class
where money is not a day-to-day struggle have time to concern themselves with
LGBT issues, global warming, what is an appropriate level of immigration, etc.
This is not to say that these issues are unimportant or should not be debated.
However, many reluctant Trump voters do not care which bathroom you use to go
potty when facing a medical procedure where the deductible runs upwards of
$10,000 or they have been replaced in their job by an H1B visa holder, or the contractor they work for has fired them and replaced them with illegal immigrants that he can pay less than minimum wage under the table. Exit
polls show that 50-60+% of respondents believed Trump to be unfit to be
president, but somewhere around a fifth of those same respondents voted for him.
The answer to the obvious “what the hell…” isn’t racism or sexism but that it
was a vote against a continuation of the status quo and the policies that got
us into this mess.
The media shouldn’t get a pass here either. A media that
stands in opposition to those in power is absolutely necessary in a healthy
society. A sycophantic media that has chosen sides is absolutely disastrous. For
several years we heard about how George W. Bush was literally Hitler; about how
not only did he want you dead, he wanted to personally pull the trigger. In 08
McCain was vilified as a racist for daring to run against the first
African-American presidential candidate. In 2012 Mitt Romney, one of the most
decent people to ever run for President, was portrayed as a racist, elitist,
megalomaniac that wanted to kill grandma and the family dog. When someone that
might actually be a narcissistic megalomaniac secured the nomination the media
had cried wolf too many times and a large segment of the population ignored them.
The social shaming practiced by John Stewart, John Oliver, Stephen
Colbert, Samantha Bee and many, many others is part of the perception of
elitism that led to the rise of Trump. It is one thing to shame public figures,
it is entirely different when you start taking aim at the yokels in flyover
country. It is easy to sit and laugh from the comfort of your living room at
how stupid the buck-toothed Nebraskan farm boy or the barefoot kid in overalls
from mountains of West Virginia are because they cling to their God and their
guns. Last night demonstrated there are a lot of those people out there, and
when properly motivated they are a force to be reckoned with. The part of the electorate
that felt powerless in society’s rush leftward expressed their anger in one of
the few ways that they could, at the ballot box.
So now what? This election is indicative that our society is
shattered and needs healing. We do not know our neighbors or anyone in our
community outside of our coworkers and friends. Don’t like the election
results? Invest in your community. Join a civic organization such as Rotary,
the Red Cross, the Salvation Army, Habitat, the Chamber of Commerce’s Young
Professionals, or any of the hundreds of other organizations out there. Don’t
tell people how much you care about them, show them. People don’t care about
your intentions, but rather your actions. Be both passionate and informed about
what you believe. Discuss your ideas with people who disagree and try to
understand why they believe what they believe. As much as I disliked the Obama
administration offering talking points of how to discuss the Affordable Care
Act with your crazy uncle at Thanksgiving, this is exactly what should be
happening. It is important that families discuss things around the dinner table
and friends discuss things over drinks or burgers or a campfire. Stop retreating to safe spaces and echo chambers. Give people
the benefit of the doubt. Differences of opinion are rarely the result of
racism or sexism or bigotry or evil intent, however if someone is saying
something hurtful, let them know and let them know why it is hurtful. Win the
war of ideas through discussion and debate instead of trying to shut down
discussion and debate. Lastly be kind and compassionate to one another. As a
people we need a lot of healing in order to make sure that last night never
happens again.